Labral tears are common in hips that do not hurt. In a prospective study of 45 volunteers with no hip pain, history of injury or surgery, 69 percent had a labral tear on MRI and 73 percent had some abnormality, more often with age (Register et al., 2012). Across 29 studies, labral tears were found in 54 percent of people without hip pain and 62 percent of people with it (Heerey et al., 2018). The tear itself separates the two groups poorly.
The cartilage separates them better. In the same review, cartilage defects were found in 12 percent of painless hips and 64 percent of painful ones (Heerey et al., 2018). If your report mentions the cartilage of the socket or the ball, that is the line to ask about.
Bone shape is common too. Across 26 studies of 2,114 hips in people with no symptoms, cam morphology was present in 37 percent overall and in 55 percent of athletes (Frank et al., 2015). A cam or pincer shape on your report is a description of your anatomy, not proof that it is the cause of your pain.
A diagnosis needs three things. The international consensus on femoroacetabular impingement syndrome requires symptoms, positive clinical signs and imaging findings together (Griffin et al., 2016). Imaging alone is not a diagnosis, and that principle applies to the labrum as much as to the bone shape.
It does not decide between physiotherapy and surgery. That decision rests on how much the hip limits you, your age, the state of the cartilage and how the hip responds to a proper course of rehabilitation. The trials below show why.